Catching Lightning in a Bottle in Small Town Ohio
Phelan Insurance Agency in Versailles, Ohio is a tale of success for attracting and developing young talent in a small, rural town. In a small town like Versailles, sourcing and retaining young talent at a local business is a challenge, but Phelan Insurance has figured out its own secret formula. About ten years ago, the […]
Valuation Views: 2025 Q3 Marketplace Report
The New Competitive Edge: Attracting and Developing the Next Generation In today’s competitive insurance landscape, staffing transcends routine hiring; it’s a strategic imperative. IA Valuations’ 2025 Q3 data shows that agencies with a higher proportion of younger producers significantly outperform their peers. Agencies with 41% of producers under age 35 (among those over $5M in […]
Is Now the Right Time to Transition Your Agency? 10 Critical Factors to Consider
Transitioning ownership of your insurance agency isn’t a decision you make lightly. It’s the culmination of decades of work, relationships, and strategic planning. Yet many agency owners struggle with the fundamental question: When is the right time?
Private Equity in Insurance: What Independent Agencies Need to Know
What Drives Agency Valuations in Today’s Private Equity Landscape The insurance brokerage industry has undergone a fundamental transformation over the past decade. Private equity capital has flooded the space, creating approximately 45 institutional buyers actively consolidating the fragmented landscape of about 35,000 independent agencies. For agency owners navigating this market, whether considering a sale, planning […]
Minimizing the Risks of an Agency Acquisition: Lessons From Those Who Have Been There
Buying or selling an independent insurance agency can be one of the fastest ways to spark growth, but it’s not without risk. Financial hurdles, cultural misalignment, and integration challenges can turn what looks like a great opportunity into a headache. A group of industry leaders recently sat down for a candid conversation about what makes […]
Independent Insurance Agencies and the Evolving M&A Landscape
The independent insurance agency (IA) system is in the midst of a significant evolution. In a recent conversation between industry leaders, experts from across the country weighed in on where the IA market is headed, what’s driving M&A activity, and how agencies can better position themselves for growth or exit. Among the featured voices were […]
2025 Q1 Marketplace Report
2025 Q1 MARKETPLACE REPORT – AGENT/BROKER M&A ACTIVITY 2024 was the year of the Mega Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A). With four deals accounting for over $35B in M&A activity, 2024 represented another year of consolidation in the independent agency space. The IA system has been experiencing heavy M&A activity since 2014 when Private Equity (PE) […]
The Power of Preparation – How Asking for Help Can Drive Growth
One of the most noble things you can do as a business owner is recognize when you need help and ask for it. Dan Kiesewetter, of Kiesewetter Insurance in Farmington, IL, began contemplating selling his agency when he came to terms with the fact that his small agency in rural Illinois did not have the […]
Navigating Private Equity in the Independent Agent System: Strategic Insights for Agency Owners
The world of independent insurance agencies is undergoing transformational change transformational change as private equity (PE) continues to reshape the industry landscape. In a recent discussion, experts Jeff Smith and Jarod Steed from IA Valuations, along with Dan Girardi from Keystone Agency Partners and James Parker from BroadStreet Partners, explored how private equity’s influence is […]
2024 State of Independent Insurance Agency Valuations – IA Valuations Webinar Recap
IA Valuations recently held a webinar discussing 2024 Independent Agency M&A Trends and Predictions. IA Valuations’ CEO, Jeff Smith, and Director of Business Planning and Valuations, Craig Niess, hosted three panelists: Mike Wagar from Westfield Bank, Dan Girardi from Keystone Agency Partners, and Rob Smith from Fideles Advisors. These panelists were selected due to their […]