In a recent conversation among industry experts, Jeff Smith and Jarod Steed from IA Valuations, Dan Girardi from Keystone Agency Partners, and James Parker from BroadStreet Partners, the group discussed the evolving role of private equity (PE) in the independent insurance agency sector. This insightful exchange provided a deep dive into how private equity’s involvement is reshaping the landscape for agencies, driving growth, and influencing future strategies.
The Rise of Private Equity in Insurance Agencies
Private equity has increasingly made its way into the insurance industry, particularly in the independent agency sector. Jeff smith from IA Valuations explained that this trend has accelerated over the past few years, with more PE firms seeing independent agencies as lucrative investments due to their recurring revenue, scalability, and compulsory nature in the economy. Smith emphasized that agencies are highly attractive to private equity because they offer recurring revenue models and can often be scaled through acquisitions of smaller agencies.
Dan Girardi of Keystone Agency Partners echoed these sentiments, noting that private equity’s entrance into the industry has been a game-changer for many agencies. PE firms bring with them not only capital, but also strategic management practices aimed at driving efficiency, growth, and value. “Agencies that partner with private equity are able to access resources they wouldn’t have otherwise had,” said Girardi. He highlighted that agencies backed by private equity are often better positioned to acquire other agencies, invest in technology, and develop comprehensive business strategies that drive long-term success.
Strategic Partnerships and Growth Opportunities
One of the most significant advantages of private equity involvement is the opportunity for independent agencies to engage in strategic partnerships. Jarod Steed from IA Valuations pointed out that private equity firms typically seek to create partnerships that align the interests of both the agency owners and investors. This alignment is crucial for long-term success, as it incentivizes growth and operational improvements within the agencies. “Private equity helps agency owners who want to remain engaged in the business while also seeking the capital and resources needed to grow,” Steed mentioned.
James Parker of BroadStreet Partners added that these partnerships are not one-size-fits-all. Different private equity firms offer different levels of involvement in the day-to-day operations of an agency. Some prefer a hands-off approach, letting agency leaders run their businesses autonomously, while others bring in more hands-on management practices. Parker stressed the importance of choosing a private equity partner that shares the same vision and values as the agency’s leadership. “It’s about finding the right fit – someone who understands your business and can help you grow without compromising what makes your agency unique,” Parker stated.
The Impact on Agency Valuations
A key theme in the conversation was the impact of private equity on agency valuations. According to Smith, the influx of private equity capital into the industry has led to increased competition for acquiring agencies, which has in turn driven up valuations. Agencies are now more valuable than ever, especially those with a proven track record of profitability and growth. However, Smith cautioned that high valuations come with higher expectations. “While private equity can offer a significant boost in terms of valuation, they also expect performance. Agencies need to have strong fundamentals in place to meet those expectations,” he said.
Girardi expanded on this by explaining that private equity firms are focused on creating value over the long term, which means agencies need to be prepared for operational changes. This can include anything from improving internal processes to leveraging data analytics to better understand market trends and consumer behavior. “Private equity is looking for sustainable growth, and that often requires making adjustments to how the agency operates,” Girardi noted.
Challenges and Considerations
While private equity offers numerous benefits, there are also challenges that agencies must consider. Parker highlighted the potential loss of control as one of the main concerns for agency owners. “When you bring in a private equity partner, you’re often giving up a certain degree of control over how your agency is run,” he said. This can be difficult for owners who are used to having full autonomy over their business decisions. However, Parker pointed out that the right private equity partner will work collaboratively with the agency’s leadership team to ensure that their vision and goals are aligned. Parker made a very high-level statement about private equity acquisitions that all agency owners should be aware of: “As a general rule, the higher the price of the offer, the more an owner should expect reorganization of their agency by the buyer.”
Another challenge is the cultural fit between the agency and the private equity firm. Steed emphasized that not every agency is a good match for private equity, and it’s essential for agency owners to thoroughly vet potential partners. “It’s not just about the money,” Steed remarked. “It’s about finding a partner who shares your values, understands your business, and is willing to support your long-term goals.” He advised agency owners who are considering the private equity route to take their time in choosing a partner to ensure that they are comfortable with the level of involvement the PE firm will have in their business.
The Future of Private Equity in Insurance Agencies
Looking ahead, the role of private equity in the independent insurance agency industry is expected to grow even further. Smith believes that as more PE firms realize the potential for growth and profitability in this space, competition for acquiring agencies will increase. This could lead to even higher valuations and more consolidation within the industry.
However, both Smith and Girardi reemphasized that private equity is not the right choice for every agency. While the benefits are clear – access to capital, resources, and strategic guidance – agency owners need to carefully consider whether private equity aligns with their vision for the future of their business. “It’s a big decision,” said Girardi.
Parker concluded the conversation by noting that the key to success in partnering with private equity, if you choose to, lies in the agency’s ability to adapt an innovate. “The industry is changing rapidly,” Parker stated.
Conclusion
The conversation between Jeff Smith, Jarod Steed, Dan Girardi, and James Parker highlighted the growing influence of private equity in the independent insurance agency industry. While private equity offers significant opportunities for growth, it also comes with challenges that agency owners must carefully consider. By aligning with the right private equity partner, agencies can unlock new levels of success, but the decision to partner with PE must be made with a clear understanding of the long-term implications. As the industry continues to evolve, private equity is likely to play an increasingly prominent role, shaping the future of independent agencies for years to come.
IA Valuations represents independent agencies in both buy-side and sell-side advising. We help broker deals between retail agencies as well as some to PE buyers, if that is what the agency chooses to go with. If you are looking for business consulting, need help deciding what’s right for your agency, or are in search of someone to represent your agency in a sale, please consider IA Valuations. Get started by emailing contact@iavaluations.com.
By: Jeff Smith, JD, CIC, CAE and Jarod Steed
This article was written with a transcription of the conversation and Chat GPT’s assistance.
About IA Valuations and Agency Link – Founded in 2017, the IA Valuations team has performed over 270 valuations to independent insurance agencies across the U.S. Our advisors have 25+ years of experience guiding agency owners on maximizing their agency value, planning, and legal needs for ownership transition. In addition, IA Valuations has provided perpetuation planning, financial modeling and business planning for independent insurance agencies. Finally, IA Valuations has advised dozens of agency owners on selling their agencies through our Agency Link process. Agency Link is a platform that connects buyers and sellers together to further the growth and strength of the IA system. To learn more about IA Valuations, please visit IAValuations.com or contact@iavaluations.com.
The information provided in these documents is general in nature and shall not be construed as personal legal, tax or financial advice for your situation. Please contact@iavaluations.com to discuss your personal situation.
Copyright ©2024 by IA Valuations and Ohio Insurance Agents Association (OIA). All rights reserved. No portion of this document may be reproduced in any manner without the prior written consent of IA Valuations or OIA. In addition, this document may not be posted as a link on any public or private website without the prior written consent of IA Valuations or OIA.